
REVISTA ODONTOLOGÍA VITAL
ROVODONTOLOGÍA VITAL P. 75
No. 43, Vol 2, 68-78 2025 (23) I ISSN:2215-5740
closed reduction of nasal bone fractures,
emphasizing the common use of closed reduction
for simple nasal fractures (Rafiq et al., 2023).
According to a systematic review by James et al.,
the success rate of closed reduction of nasal
fractures was 70% to 95% when performed early
(James et al., 2020).
A study by Choi et al. showed that closed
reduction in patients with nasal fractures can
significantly minimize post-operative septal
deviation in certain fracture types (Choi et al.,
2022).
Conversely, Plath et al. found that individuals with
nasal bone fractures generally experience more
aesthetic improvements than functional benefits
following closed reduction (Plath et al., 2023).
These studies underscore closed reduction’s
ongoing relevance and effectiveness in managing
nasal bone fractures.
Functional and Aesthetic Considerations
Complications arising from the closed reduction of
a nasal fracture can be categorized into functional
issues and deformities. Functionally, nasal
fractures may result in septal deviation, impacting
respiratory function even if the septum itself is not
fractured. Choi et al. studied the impact of closed
reduction in various nasal fracture patterns
(without septal fractures) and its implications for
septal deviation, finding that closed reduction
significantly reduced septal deviation in all fracture
types studied (unilateral, bilateral, and
comminuted). However, comminuted fractures
may result in persistent septal deviation despite
the intervention (Choi et al., 2022). The aesthetic
outcome depends on the level of deformity
caused by the fracture, and evaluating it is always
a challenge. Closed nasal reduction is the ideal
treatment for cases with minor deformities or
when aesthetics are
not a priority for the patient; otherwise, the ideal
treatment is rhinoseptoplasty. Besmens et al.
reported that the incidence of nasal deformities
following reduction, which require rhinoplasty or
rhinoseptoplasty, falls between 14% and 15%
(Besmens et al., 2023).
Regarding patient perception, Park et al. examined
patients’ quality of life post-closed reduction for
nasal bone fractures, shedding light on the overall
satisfaction and outcomes following the procedure
(Park et al., 2023). Furthermore, a more recent study
conducted by Sánchez-Álvarez et al. evaluated
aesthetic satisfaction using a subjective scale, and
the median total score increased from 32 to 72
points after closed reduction. Items related to size,
shape, and overall aesthetic appearance received
the highest scores (Sánchez-Álvarez et al., 2023).
These studies provide updated insights into the
functional and aesthetic outcomes of closed
reduction in nasal fractures, highlighting the
importance of patient satisfaction and longterm
results.
Time of intervention
Opinions vary regarding the appropriate timing for
intervention in isolated nasal bone fractures and
their impact on outcomes. Many experts
recommend early reduction for pediatric patients,
typically within 7 days due to their faster healing
rates, and within 10 days post-injury for adults
(Wang et al., 2019).
Trujillo et al. suggest an immediate closed
reduction is feasible if the patient receives care
within 3 to 6 hours of the injury, before significant
swelling occurs. Beyond this period, it is generally
advisable to postpone the procedure until the
swelling subsides, which may take up to 14 days in
adults.